Click Here to Go to the Ashbrook Center's Homepage

Subscribe to Our Email Update
 
SEARCH
 

Home



Support the Ashbrook Center




No Left Turns:
The Ashbrook
Center Blog




  Ashbrook
Podcasts


Podcast Index

What's a Podcast?

Peter Schramm's "You Americans"

Ashbrook Events

Teaching American History




Ashbrook Scholar Program



Social Studies
Teacher Seminars






Congressional Academy for American History and Civics





Presidential Academy for American History and Civics





Master of American History and Government





American Speeches, Letters, and Documents
On-Line Library






Constitutional
Convention


Federalist-
Antifederalist
Debate


Ratification of
the Constitution


Founding
Political Parties




Ashbrook 
Columnists 

Robert Alt

Andrew E. Busch

John C. Eastman

Christopher Flannery

David Forte

Patrick J. Garrity

Steven Hayward

Joseph Knippenberg

Terrence O. Moore

Lucas Morel

Mackubin T. Owens

Peter W. Schramm

David Tucker

John Zvesper




Calendar of Events



Subscribe to Our
E-Mail Update





Book of the Week:
Plato's Philosophers: The Coherence of the Dialogues
by Catherine H. Zuckert




Book of the Week Archive



Vindicating The
Founders.com




Classics of Strategy and Diplomacy



Suggested Articles



Who Was
John Ashbrook?




Other Sites of Interest

Pan Am 103:
The Verdict Is In

Editorial
January 2001

by: David Tucker


A Scottish court sitting in the Netherlands this week convicted a Libyan of murder for the bombing of Pan Am flight 103 in December 1988. This verdict is the culmination of a long process. The bombing occurred over Scotland killing all 259 people on board, including 189 U.S. citizens, and 11 on the ground. The investigation continued for three years until U.S. and British officials concluded that two Libyans, one a member of Libyan leader Muammar Qaddafi’s intelligence services, had organized the bombing.

Armed with evidence gathered during the investigation, the United States and Great Britain, in March 1993, got the United Nations to impose sanctions on Libya until Qaddafi turned over the accused. He did so, after negotiating over the location of the trial, in 1999. The trial began in May, 2000. Now, the verdict is in. Abdel Basset Ali al-Megrahi, the Libyan intelligence officer, was found guilty. His alleged accomplice, Lamen Khalifa Fhimah, who worked for the Libyan airline, was acquitted.

What was on trial in the Netherlands was not just the two Libyans, however. Since the late 1980s, the use of legal proceedings against those who commit terrorism has been one of principal ways in which the United States has tried to combat terrorism. Since 1993 more than a dozen terrorists, some associated with attacks that have killed and wounded hundreds, have been brought back to the United States for trial.

The results of the Pan Am 103 legal process will raise again the question of whether this method of combating terrorism is effective. The bombing of Pan Am 103 could not have occurred without Qaddafi’s authorization, yet he is still free. The security services that made the bombing possible are still operating and could organize other attacks. Similarly, Usama bin Laden, the financier and facilitator of some of the worst terrorism of the 1990s, remains safe in Afghanistan, able to support more attacks, even though some of those who carried out these attacks are among those we have arrested recently.

It is certainly the case that the use of legal proceedings against terrorists is not a decisive weapon. But it does have beneficial results. The painstaking and quite remarkable reconstruction of what happened to Pan Am 103 and who committed the crime, allowed the United States to build support for sanctions against Qaddafi. Over time, these sanctions had an effect on the Libyan economy and, it appears, on Qaddafi himself, who came to feel isolated. The economic and psychological costs of sanctions were a significant element in the long multifaceted campaign to persuade Qaddafi to curtail his support for terrorism. This campaign has worked. Qaddafi is not the problem he was in the 1980s.

Similarly, following the indictment of Usama bin Ladin in 1998 for his part in the bombings of two U.S. embassies in east Africa, pressure has mounted on the rulers of Afghanistan, who have given him shelter. Both the United States and the United Nations have placed sanctions on the country, for example, demanding that bin Ladin be turned over to the United States or a third country for trial. Again, such measures will not produce results over night or by themselves. But over time, with other measures, the case of Libya and Pan Am 103 suggests, they will.

This is one reason why we should not give up the strategy of using legal proceedings against terrorists. Another reason is that we have few, if any, alternatives. Some counsel the use of military force, for example. But this is one of the weakest tools we have in the fight against terrorism. We are more vulnerable to terrorist attack than the terrorist are to our military force. In any campaign of tit-for-tat violence, we are likely to come out the worse.

In fighting terrorism, as in all our national security concerns, we should fight in a way that plays to our strengths. In the case of terrorism, this means using criminal investigations and diplomatic and economic sanctions. It means continuing our now more than three decade-long struggle to shape international opinion, making terrorism illegitimate and isolating those who support it.

Such measures, employed to good effect in the Pan Am 103 case, will not produce a decisive victory over terrorism. Such a victory is not possible. But if we remain steadfast, accepting inconclusive results and setbacks but struggling on, in the long-term, slowly but surely, the ultimate verdict will go in our favor.

David Tucker is a Member of the Board of Advisors at the Ashbrook Center for Public Affairs at Ashland University and an Associate Professor at the United States Naval Postgraduate School.



 


Printer-Friendly Version

Upcoming Events

Michael Burlingame on Abraham Lincoln
Friday, February 19


Recent Publications


Progressive Bigotry and Natural Law by Richard Adams

Advisers, Not Advocates by Mackubin T. Owens

Conservative Malaise? by Julie Ponzi

Are Democrats Deluding Themselves About ’94? by Andrew E. Busch

Making Sense of the Missile Shield Bait and Switch by Rebeccah Heinrichs

Abraham Lincoln on Constitution and Character by Joseph Knippenberg

What Will the Republicans Do? by Andrew E. Busch

What Does Obama Do Next? by Andrew E. Busch

The World Has Changed by Peter W. Schramm

The Conservative Challenge by Charles R. Kesler

Hallowed Ground by Christopher Flannery

Dear Mr. President by Andrew E. Busch

Money for Nothing by Joseph Knippenberg

Bourbon Democrats by Andrew E. Busch

Questions for Symbolic Sotomayor and Roadrunner Republicans by Ken Thomas


Audio Archive


John Kasich on the Future of Ohio (2009)

John Moser on Captain America (2009)

Steven Hayward on Ronald Reagan (2009)

Tim Timken on Private Enterprise (2009)

Sally Pipes on Health Care Reform (2009)

Colleen Sheehan on James Madison (2009)

Robert J. Norrell on Booker T. Washington (2009)

James Piereson on the Kennedy Assassination (2009)

Peter W. Schramm on Abraham Lincoln (2009)

The No Left Turns Bloggers on Election 2008 (2008)

Conference on the Presidency and the Courts featuring President George W. Bush (2008)

Jeb Bush on America’s Promise (2008)

Harry V. Jaffa on the Lincoln-Douglas Debates (2007)

Glenn Beck on Militant Islam (2006)

Lamar Alexander on Education (2006)

Karl Rove on Conservatism (2005)

James McPherson on the Battle of Antietam (2005)

David Hackett Fischer on Liberty and Freedom (2004)

William Bennett on the Politics of War (2004)

Edwin Meese on Homeland Security (2003)

Barbara Bush on CSPAN (2003)

Victor Davis Hanson on Terrorism (2003)

Benjamin Netanyahu on Attaining Peace (2002)

Clarence Thomas on the Supreme Court (1999)

Margaret Thatcher on Ronald Reagan and Freedom (1993)

Lynne V. Cheney on Academic Freedom (1992)

Dick Cheney on American Foreign Policy (1991)

Ronald Reagan on John Ashbrook (1983)

  Real Logo
Visit our archive of over 200 other Ashbrook speeches at
audio.ashbrook.org or subscribe to our
Events Podcast.








ASHBROOK SCHOLAR PROGRAM | MASTER OF AMERICAN HISTORY AND GOVERNMENT |
PUBLICATIONS | EVENTS | PODCASTS | NO LEFT TURNS BLOG | AUDIO ARCHIVE | DONATE | ABOUT US

 

Ashbrook Scholar Program:  Home | Apply Online | Request More Information | Course of Study | Faculty | Speakers |
Why Study History or Political Science? | Internship Opportunities | Student Publications | Financial Assistance | FAQ | Contact Us

Master of American History and Government:  Home | About | Admission | Schedule of Courses | Course Registration | Tuition | Faculty | Request More Information

TeachingAmericanHistory.org:  Home | Saturday Seminars | Summer Institutes | Partner on a Teaching American History Grant | Historical Documents Library | Audio Lectures and Discussions | Constitutional Convention | Ratification of the Constitution

Presidential Academy for American History and Civics:  Home | About the Program | Documents and Texts | Faculty | Itinerary | Application

Congressional Academy for American History and Civics:  Home | About the Program | Documents and Texts | Faculty | Itinerary | Application

Podcasts:  Home | What's a Podcast? | Subscribe

No Left Turns Blog  Home | Archive | Postings by Author | Comments by Our Readers | What's in a Name? | RSS Site Feed

Publications:  Home | Editorials | On Principle | Right from the Center | Dialogues | Books | Monographs |
Ashbrook Statesmanship Theses | Res Publica | Publication Request Form | Publications by Subject

Events:  Home | John M. Ashbrook Memorial Dinner | Major Issues Lecture Series | Colloquium |
Van Meter Scholarship Luncheon | Conferences and Special Events | Calendar of Events | On-Line Speeches (RealAudio)

About Us:  Home | Board of Advisors | Staff | Who Was John M. Ashbrook | Support the Ashbrook Center |
Map and Directions

 

The Ashbrook Center is a townhall.com Member Organization.

Verizon Foundation
Support for ashbrook.org is provided by the Verizon Foundation.


John M. Ashbrook Center for Public Affairs
Ashland University
401 College Avenue | Ashland, Ohio 44805
(419) 289-5411  |   (877) 289-5411 (Toll Free)